IPB

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

> Is Torture Justified?, University Paper..
Slimshady
post 03/07/07 11:39am
Post #1


Colonel
Group Icon

Group: {MOB}
Posts: 1401
Joined: December 28th 2004
Member No.: 1005
Xfire: slimshady200



I'm writing a paper and whether or not torture is a justifiable act. I just wanna hear some your opinions, later i'll put up some scenarios to see how you fell about them.

Thanks


--------------------
IPB Image
Sig by Pezking.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Reply to this topicStart new topic
Replies
Slimshady
post 03/08/07 11:34am
Post #2


Colonel
Group Icon

Group: {MOB}
Posts: 1401
Joined: December 28th 2004
Member No.: 1005
Xfire: slimshady200



QUOTE(M@ster of Dis@ster @ 03/08/07 12:30pm) *

You should read the article that I linked. Miltary teachers believe torture almost always elicits bad or useless info. However, aside from that, have we forgotten that we got to this point in history where the free nations of the world dominate PRECISELY because we HAVE NOT made torture and mayhem a part of our society? Haven't we won because we have consistently been BETTER than them, not just in the size of our militaries, but in our will to fight for what is good and right because we know, as a whole, our society has been so much more worth fighting for than one where the governments torture and abuse anyone they perceive an enemy?


Whether we think torture is right or not, it has been and still will be used when needed. If you think that the US has not restored to torture many times, then you are completely wrong. There has been many cases or torture that even the public knows about, let alone what we don't know about. Not in all cases are we the ones doing the torturing but us sending our prisioners to Jordon where torturing is allowed to try to gain information for our beneifits is the same as us doing the torturing.

However, asking the question is torturing justified.. no it can't be, but are we and will we still try to use it to save lives, yes. The question is will we involve in our justice system.. for example giving a torture warrant? Given from the highest levels of goverment for only extreme cases, and if torture is done without this warrant the person who done it will be held responsible. Maybe if we had something like this in place it would cut down on the amount of unneeded torture that goes on. Such as at guantanamo prision.
Maybe something like this may help?


Thanks lead, i'll look into those.


--------------------
IPB Image
Sig by Pezking.
User is offlineProfile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
Slimshady   Is Torture Justified?   03/07/07 11:39am
pezking   Yes, under certain circumstances. I'm not for...   03/07/07 12:21pm
Cross of Iron   My veiw on torture,is that..YES it could give you ...   03/07/07 1:01pm
blk96gt   I agree with what pezking said, but I have some mo...   03/07/07 1:09pm
M@ster of Dis@ster   I agree with what pezking said, but I have some m...   03/07/07 1:58pm
blk96gt   Geez, why are you guys fighting Al Qeda and the ...   03/07/07 3:49pm
)--S@B0T-->   I agree with what pezking said, but I have some m...   03/07/07 4:58pm
Old Man Mike   Jack Bauer for president. Enough said. Old Man M...   03/07/07 1:12pm
Slimshady   One question though. After you chop of someone...   03/07/07 3:04pm
M@ster of Dis@ster   One question though. After you chop of someone...   03/07/07 4:06pm
flatliner   My wife thinks torture is fine... wait, did I say...   03/07/07 3:37pm
Meowman   My wife thinks torture is fine... wait, did I sa...   03/07/07 6:38pm
pezking   Actually, I don't watch 24 or CSI. I'm re...   03/07/07 4:59pm
M@ster of Dis@ster   Actually, I don't watch 24 or CSI. I'm r...   03/07/07 5:33pm
Bargod   I'll try to find the issue of New Yorker that ...   03/07/07 5:19pm
pezking   In regards to Saddam's capture, not only did t...   03/07/07 10:30pm
Hellfighter   What context do you mean justifiable? On a persona...   03/07/07 11:40pm
Leadmagnet   slim, seeing as this is university level work, you...   03/08/07 2:47am
T/A6Pak   Do the ends justify the means? This is very import...   03/08/07 7:58am
Major.Pain   In wartime we (and anyone else in the war) will us...   03/08/07 10:05am
M@ster of Dis@ster   In wartime we (and anyone else in the war) will u...   03/08/07 11:00am
pezking   Why are you saying that it's based on a black ...   03/08/07 11:11am
M@ster of Dis@ster   Why are you saying that it's based on a black...   03/08/07 11:24am
pezking   You're confusing me with other people's po...   03/08/07 11:32am
Slimshady   You should read the article that I linked. Miltar...   03/08/07 11:34am
Genocide Junkie   I'm feeling tortured now.....   03/08/07 2:19pm


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



- Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 05/03/26 10:04pm
Skin Designed by Canucks Fan Zone